You are in:  Women's Institute > Campaigns and projects > Country of origin labelling >

Country of origin labelling

Why is the WI campaigning for clearer country of origin labelling?
WI members believe that shoppers want accurate information about their food in order to make informed choices. This includes identifying where a product comes from, alongside commonplace information such as its price or nutritional content.

Few foods legally require a country of origin label (COOL), unless not providing one would mislead shoppers. Moreover, a legal loophole means that even when a country of origin label is given, it may be confusing to many consumers.

Foodstuffs are labelled as the product of the country in which they underwent the last "substantial change". This means that a pork pie made in a factory in Britain can be labelled as "made in the UK" even if it is made with imported meat. For many shoppers this is misleading as they assume, for example, that "British sausages" will be made with meat from British pigs.

Manufacturers like this system because it is simple and allows them to source ingredients widely without changing labels. But food is not something that is produced in a factory. It is produced from ingredients grown and reared in fields and shoppers want information that reflects a product's true providence from field to fork.
What is the WI calling for?
The WI is calling for:

  • Mandatory COOL for all fresh meat products.
  • In processed meat and fish products, mandatory country of origin labelling for the meat and fish ingredient as well as the finished product, to enable consumers to identify the country of origin of all key ingredients.
  • More accurate country of origin labelling of meat and fish products, so that a single country of origin can be given only if the animal was born, reared and slaughtered in one country, to enable consumers to track an animal throughout its life.

Knowing where a food was produced can give some indication as to whether it was in season, how it may have been grown and its food miles. Different countries, even within the EU, have differing standards of animal welfare, meaning shoppers may want to avoid meat sourced from certain countries. Shoppers need accurate information on where their food comes from in order to make these choices.

Increasing numbers of shoppers are deciding that they actively want to support British farmers through their food choices. Many WIs have longstanding links with their local farmers and are deeply aware of the problems facing British agriculture. However, shoppers cannot actively seek out British produce without accurate country of origin labelling.

The campaign so far

The UK cannot introduce country of origin labelling without cooperation from other European states. The European Union is currently debating proposals to reform food labelling to make country of origin labelling mandatory. Both the European parliament and the Council of the European Union must agree to any reforms.
The aim is for new, improved food labelling laws to take affect across Europe from 2013.

There are different views within the European Union about whether labelling should be mandatory or not. Representatives from the 27 EU states at the Agricultural and Fisheries Council discussed this issue in July 2009 and mandatory country of origin labelling was narrowly defeated in a vote, with the previous UK Labour Government voting against, along with
9 other countries.

In June MEPs voted to support mandatory country of origin labelling
. They also voted for COOL for meat in processed products, although this may be subject to an impact assessment, and supported proposals that meat should indicate if an animal was born, reared and slaughtered in separate countries.

Ruth Bond, NFWI Chair, has written to the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs setting out the arguments for mandatory COOL. Caroline Spelman MP has responded to confirm that the government is reviewing its position and welcomes input from groups such as the WI.

What happens now

The Agricultural and Fisheries Council will now debate COOL. They do have to be mindful of what MEPS but are free to amend the proposals passed by MEPs. Support for mandatory COOL in the Council is uncertain. The ENVI commission will then scrutinise the Council's decision and vote among themselves.

The proposals will then return to the full European Parliament for a final vote by all MEPs in early 2011, most likely March. Ultimately the Council has to agree a position which is acceptable to all 27 representatives and the Council and Parliament have to agree on an acceptable position.


Act now

MEPs will have to vote again if the Council tries to water down proposals for COOL. This means that it is vital that members ask their MEPs to support the proposals throughout the summer and autumn. It is crucial that every British MEP understands this is an issue that matters to consumers.

The UK Government also needs to be aware of the WI's campaign as Defra ministers will be discussing it at the Agriculture and Fisheries Council. The coalition government has already indicated its support for clear food labelling but has not committed to mandatory schemes. It is crucial reforms are vigorous enough to guarantee clarity for consumers.
 

What you can do
1. Write to your MEP
You can use the information on this website to compose your own letter or download a template letter. Find out who your MEP is by visiting the writetothem website.

2. Write to your MP
MPs cannot vote on this issue directly but they can put pressure on the UK government to support measures in Brussels. Write to your MP setting out why this issue is important to you and encourage them to write to the Secretary of State of the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs to ask the government to back mandatory COOL.

3. Tell us your views
The NFWI has put together a short survey on members' experiences of misleading labelling and what improvements they think need to be made. It can be downloaded here. We are also asking members to send in examples of misleading packing. Please post clean packets and labels to: COOL campaign, 104 New Kings Road, London, SW6 4LY.